Selling Your Products Through Marketplace Websites – Is It Worth The Risk?

Photo by Lucrezia Carnelos on Unsplash
12 months ago

Online retailing is experiencing a remarkable surge, with approximately one-quarter of the total retail market now dominated by online sales. Businesses that are not actively involved in e-commerce are already at risk of failing, as an increasing number of customers have shifted towards the convenience of ordering products online.

Embracing e-commerce has become essential for retailers to keep pace with the evolving consumer preferences and tap into the significant opportunities it presents, whether by selling products independently or through a marketplace. While marketplace e-commerce offers convenience and access to a broad audience, venturing into independent e-commerce stores promises greater control and brand identity. However, businesses must be prepared to tackle the challenges and invest resources to ensure the success of their e-commerce venture.

Selling on Marketplace Websites

Marketplace e-commerce refers to the online platforms where multiple vendors can list and sell their products to a vast and diverse customer base. Leading examples like Amazon, eBay, Etsy, and Alibaba have become household names, showcasing the tremendous impact of this business model on a global scale.

When it comes to selling on marketplace websites, the prospect of reaching millions of customers worldwide is undeniably attractive. Such platforms offer a remarkable opportunity for instant exposure, making them especially enticing for budding businesses seeking quick traction and market visibility. Other benefits include the following:

  • Better payment methods, logistics, and customer service: Marketplace platforms offer a ready-made and efficient infrastructure to manage key aspects of the selling journey. They handle everything from seamless payment transactions and swift shipping logistics to attentive customer service. This relieves sellers from operational hassles, allowing them to concentrate on refining their products and marketing strategies.
  • Trust and credibility associated with established platforms: Common marketplaces have earned global consumer trust, and by leveraging the credibility of these platforms, you can enhance your brand reputation. This often leads to increased sales and customer loyalty, as potential buyers feel more at ease making purchases through these trusted channels.
  • Access to an established customer base: Marketplaces could have millions of active consumers, and this gives businesses the opportunity to reach an existing customer base to fuel expansion. So, with minimal effort, vendors can expose their products and gain consumers in an organic way.

Despite the advantages, venturing into the marketplace arena presents some challenges that sellers should be aware of, like:

  • Competition with other businesses: Marketplaces also draw a large number of sellers competing for the same customers. The presence of numerous competitors on the same platform could possibly overshadow smaller businesses, impacting their visibility.
  • Platform fees and commissions impacting profit margins: Engaging in marketplace transactions isn’t without its costs. Sellers often face platform fees and commissions per sale, which can reduce profit margins, particularly for businesses operating on a lean budget or those selling lower-cost items.
  • Less control: Selling through marketplaces means you’ll have to strictly follow certain policies, and that limits expression and personalization amongst brands. This usually makes it difficult to differentiate the brand from competitors.

Impact on Small Businesses

As marketplace e-commerce continues to change the world of retail, it has its impacts on small businesses as well. On the one hand, these platforms provide small enterprises with access to an extensive customer base. However, the rapid growth and competitiveness of these marketplaces can also present challenges, as smaller businesses must navigate through heightened competition, stringent policies, and fees to establish a strong presence.

Also, the financial implications of returns can significantly impact a small business’s cash flow. Refunds lead to a reduction in revenue and the potential loss of already incurred expenses, affecting profitability. The uncertainty surrounding when and how many returns will occur can make it challenging for businesses to forecast and allocate resources effectively.

For small businesses with limited resources, handling a high volume of returns and refunds can strain their operational capabilities, diverting attention from core business functions. Additionally, marketplace platforms often charge fees for processing returns, further impacting profit margins and overall financial stability.

Would it be Better to Own Your E-commerce Store?

Owning an independent e-commerce store offers businesses the option of full control over their online presence and customer experience and allows them to build their own special brand identity. Steps to owning your e-commerce store start with identifying your niche and planning your business model. Then you hire an e-commerce designer to create a visually appealing and user-friendly website. Choose your aesthetic, set up your store, and create attractive content. Launch your store and implement a strategic marketing plan to drive traffic and boost sales. While this sounds easy, there are certain rewards and risks that come with this as well.

On the topic of rewards, businesses have the privilege of unrestricted customization of their branding, offering a unique and engaging customer experience. This individuality promotes direct customer relationships, fostering loyalty and repeat business. The flexibility inherent in independent stores allows for swift adaptation to market trends and customer feedback, offering a competitive edge. Additionally, by bypassing marketplace fees, independent e-commerce stores often enjoy higher profit margins, enhancing the financial viability of the venture.

On the other hand, some risks include the fact that there is a need for financial commitment for initial setup and ongoing costs like website maintenance and digital marketing. Additionally, owners shoulder operational responsibilities such as managing website functionality, payment gateways, and customer support. Unlike marketplace platforms with ready-made audiences, independent stores require more effort in building and sustaining a customer base through marketing and SEO strategies. Moreover, independent stores have to compete with established marketplaces like Amazon and eBay, which can be challenging for emerging businesses.


Selling your products on marketplace websites can be worth it; however, it depends on what your business can afford. Your long-term business goals and budget play a huge role in this choice. While marketplace websites offer instant access to a vast audience on trusted platforms, owning an independent store empowers you with greater control and direct customer relationships. You need to put all that into consideration and carefully weigh the rewards and risks to get the perfect fit for your business.

Don't Miss

Photo by Karolina Grabowska from Pexels

The 3 Common E-commerce Store Shipping Mistakes To Avoid

Shipping is the cornerstone of any e-commerce site’s success. It is a
Photo by Zyro on Unsplash

Maximising Profit: Essential Tips To Boost Your eCommerce Business

In a world that is increasingly digital, eCommerce has taken centre stage